The Fool Killer

 

The Fool Killer (1965)

A Haunting, Dreamlike Post-Civil War Odyssey

★★★½☆

Watched 15 Jan 2025 — A unique, hard-to-find gem that captures the simmering tension and brutality of an undeveloped world.

Directed by Servando González, The Fool Killer is an odd, dreamlike film that follows a 12-year-old runaway escaping an abusive foster home. Set in the post-Civil War era, the movie evokes the eerie tone of an extended Twilight Zone episode, minus the supernatural elements. Its episodic structure—marked by unusual montages and strange vocalized inner monologues—creates an uneasy energy. While it occasionally meanders, the film finds its footing and crystallizes its themes upon the introduction of a PTSD-afflicted soldier, leading to a truly surprising payoff.

"There is a feeling of uneasiness which permeates the film as it probably should. A character being 12 years old in a brutal world should feel like they are in danger."

— Ray Manukay

🎬 Cast & Crew

• Director: Servando González
• Starring: Anthony Perkins, Edward Albert
• Supporting: Dana Elcar, Henry Hull, Salome Jens
• Cinematography: Alex Phillips Jr.

The Vision

González’s vision is far from the whimsy of Huckleberry Finn; instead, he leans into a stark, brutal reality captured in simmering black and white. The direction and cinematography are surprisingly strong, amplifying the sense of danger that lurks around every corner for the young protagonist. The filmmaker intentionally fosters a sense of unease, utilizing the protagonist's inner monologues to heighten the film's "odd energy." It is a unique piece of cinema that explores the vulnerability of youth in a violent, undeveloped landscape.

🎬 Cinephile Fun Facts

• Edward Albert's Debut: This film marked the professional debut of [Edward Albert](https://www.imdb.com), who would later go on to win a Golden Globe for Butterflies Are Free.
• The Perkins Connection: Anthony Perkins took this role shortly after his iconic turn in Psycho, continuing his streak of playing deeply troubled, psychologically complex characters.
• Literary Roots: The film is based on the [1954 novel by Helen Eustis](https://en.wikipedia.org), which was praised for its unique blend of Southern Gothic and coming-of-age themes.

✅ Pros

• Strong, atmospheric black-and-white cinematography.
• Powerful, thematic performance by Anthony Perkins.
• A unique, rewarding payoff and dreamlike tone.

❌ Cons

• Occasional pacing issues and meandering plot.
• Moments that feel "inappropriate" by modern standards.
• Very difficult to find on modern streaming platforms.

🏆 Final Verdict

An off-the-beaten-path recommendation for those seeking something haunting and distinctive. It’s a "hard to find gem" that balances simmering tension with a surprising, thought-provoking conclusion.

View on Letterboxd